Prior to 2019-20, there were two separate awards, Website of the Year and Publication of the Year. They have been merged into Outlet of the Year for 2020.
2022-23 - MatScouts
2021-22 - InterMat (3)
2020-21 - Des Moines Register (2)
2019-20 - PA Power Wrestling
| Publication of the Year | Website of the Year |
| 2018-19 - Not Awarded 2017-18 - Mat Talk Online Digital Publications 2016-17 - Lehigh University Wrestling News Magazine 2015-16 - Colorado Springs Gazette 2014-15 - Cedar Rapids Gazette 2013-14 - The Predicament (2) 2012-13 - Des Moines Register 2011-12 - W.I.N. Magazine (3) 2010-11 – The Guillotine (2) 2009-10 – USA Wrestler (2) 2008-09 – Pennsylvania Wrestling Newsmagazine 2007-08 – Wrestlers at the Trials & Cowboy Up 2006-07 – The History of Collegiate Wrestling 2005-06 – W.I.N. Magazine (2) 2004-05 – Wrestling USA 2003-04 – Nebraska Wrestling Illustrated 2002-03 – Grappling 2001-02 – EIWA Newsletter 2000-01 – The Crossface 1999-00 – North Carolina Mat News 1998-99 – The Predicament 1997-98 – W.I.N. Magazine 1996-97 – USA Wrestler 1995-96 – Pennsylvania Roundup 1994-95 – Indiana Grappler 1993-94 – The Guillotine 1992-93 – Amateur Wrestling News 1991-92 – The Illinois Grappler | 2018-19 - Flowrestling (2) 2017-18 - FivePointMove.com 2016-17 - IAwrestle.com 2015-16 - IndianaMat.com 2014-15 - D3wrestle.com 2013-14 - Trackwrestling.com 2012-13 - Tech-Fall.com 2011-12 - The Open Mat 2010-11 – FloWrestling 2009-10 – LighthouseWrestling.com 2008-09 – BuckeyeWrestling.com 2007-08 – Illinoismatmen.com 2006-07 – InterMat (2) 2005-06 – AmateurWrestlingPhotos.com 2004-05 – WrestlingReport.com 2003-04 – The Guillotine.com 2002-03 – The Mat (2) 2001-02 – InterMat 2000-01 – The Wrestling Mall 1999-00 – The Mat |
